Thank you for your feedback
Before troubleshooting your ship rates, you will need to be familiar with how to create and edit shipping rates and methods. If you are not familiar with this, please review How do I calculate shipping?
When troubleshooting ship rates, first view the order(s) that are miscalculating and make note of the specifics of the order that affect the shipping (i.e., ZIP code, price, shipping method, and also the ship-weight of the products if you are using the built-in shipping table or weight-based rates).
Review the orders that are not calculating correctly. Often there is something in common among the orders that are miscalculating. Look for what these orders have in common.
For example:
Review what orders your current rules are set to apply to.
Here are some things to check if some orders are not being charged, if none of your orders are being charged, or if they're being under or over-charged:
If viewing the ship rates doesn't give you the information you need, you can use Shipping and Tax Test (in the Shipping Manager) to see exactly how much was applied from each rate setting. View the problem order (or orders) and get the ZIP code, price, shipping method, and also the ship-weight of the products if you use the built-in shipping table or have weight-based rates. Enter this information in the Shipping and Tax Test section of your manager, and click Calculate.
The results will then show you how much shipping and tax would be charged, or it will show no charges if the order information you entered did not match any ship rates you have set up.